Thursday, 30 July 2015

Do Labels Last a Lifetime?


(Reflections on a life in science: #2 people and other influences)

Why science? Why not history or archaeology, English literature or the arts, woodwork or the factory line? Ultimately, I don’t know. All that is clear is illuminated, post hoc, by what now is and by the way in which one looks back along the road travelled. In short, there is a tendency to rationalise the reasons and the choices of the past in light of where one now stands. With that in mind I have nevertheless set myself the task of trying to pick out a few of the events and the people that seem to me to form some of the myriad milestones along the way. This constitutes the second post in a series of reflections on my career - the opening post is here.

There is a much-disputed saying attributed to the early Jesuit order which runs something along the lines of the following: “Give me a child until they are seven and I will give you the adult". All I want to draw out of this is the point that the earlier an influence impinges on a person’s life the smaller it has to be in order to have a profound impact in the longer term. This is not to say that we ever necessarily become ossified in our worldview, far from it. In this post, one of a series of reflections as I approach the transition into retirement from my four-decade career in research, I want to explore the influences I have discerned. The opening post may be found here; in it I made the point that the entire series is intrinsically limited by the purposeful omission of the (often hugely important) influences outside of my naively drawn ‘science compartment’. Perhaps these will emerge later – post-retirement, maybe; in the meantime, I’m hoping I can tell a vaguely coherent story in their absence. Returning to my opening questions, I will confess that the selection of options I presented was not a random one. I’m not sure I could ever truly know why the pursuit of science, and eventually the experimental physical sciences in particular, began to emerge as a front-runner. I do recall having been captivated from age five or so by events within the so-called ‘space race’, which was prominent in the decades immediately after the Second World War*. Thus, with Sputnik and Telstar and all that followed, there was a steady stream of more and more exciting news about achievements in space. Indeed, science and technology were very much to the fore, even to the extent of a UK Prime Minister (Harold Wilson) coining the phrase “the 'white heat' of scientific revolution” as a campaign slogan. It was, arguably, President Kennedy’s speech to Congress in 1961 (here) that really set the pace in terms of the overtly non-military exploration of space: stirring stuff, the like of which one rarely sees. Thus, the positive draw of science, running alongside an awareness of its potential dangers in the context of political power was established and reinforced by such events. As far as most of my acquaintances were concerned, the high point of the USA’s Apollo programme came when the Apollo 11 crew made it to the Moon and then returned. I remember the battle, such as it was, to be allowed to dominate the family’s TV on July 20th 1969 and to stay in front of it all night to watch the grainy, monochrome images of the landing and first steps … before going off to work after breakfast in the building firm that had given me a holiday job. This was definitely a favourite moment in my walk towards a career in science. However, I’d have to say that the Apollo 13 mission ‘grabbed’ me almost as much, and I still follow the ongoing 1970s Voyager deep-space programme via Twitter.
A few of the magazines I bought, read and treasured (Paris Match to help with my school French perhaps?) during the initial 1960s phase of NASA's Apollo programme which had been outlined by President Kennedy as a national goal. Inset on the right is my elementary trigonometric calculations relating to the splash-down point for one of them; I spotted this bit of mathematics on the back of an envelope from the US Information Service, from whom I obtained umpteen reports#, this one is date-stamped 1969.

Were there positive influences other than those coming out of the space race? Yes, many – it was simply that the push into space most readily piqued my interest. Coincidentally, I have recently been reminded of one of the other notable events in my early travels towards science. I found my 1964/5 collection of Discovery magazine issues in the attic a while back and have been tweeting ‘in this month, 50 years ago’ snippets via Twitter ever since. Recently, I came across a short piece on the Nimrod High Energy Accelerator at what was then the Rutherford Laboratory in Oxfordshire (and now) and recalled that I’d been shown around this in 1968/9 when I was 15 or 16 by an uncle. He designed electronic counters for the various detectors around the proton accelerator apparently; these failed to interest me whereas the high energy physics was, as far as I could understand it, fascinating. Some of life’s ‘spirals’ are noteworthy: in 1982 I joined the staff of the ISIS Neutron and Muon Source, Nimrod’s successor in that it too is a proton accelerator and occupies the same buildings – although there the similarity ends. A few days before I began drafting this post I had a ’phone conversation and e-mail exchange with one of the people putting together displays for this year’s Open Days on the site, out of which came the ‘then and now’ collage shown below. I seem not to be able to get aware from the place …
On the left, the display item put together for this year’s Harwell Campus Open Day: a rare photograph of me at about the age when I visited Nimrod and in the academic robes associated with the DSc awarded to me somewhat more recently by the University of Leicester; on the right is Discovery magazine’s image of a small part of Nimrod, June 1965.

As to the other potential choices listed at the opening of this post: history, archaeology and English literature have remained high on my list of interests, albeit as very part-time (and mostly ‘armchair’) hobbies; woodwork, for which I only ever had the most modest of aptitude, has transmuted into the distractions of DIY; for short periods of time I’ve tried the rhythms of factory and similar work and discovered that I’m not fitted for it at all. Of all the headings in the list it is perhaps the arts that is most curious: although I love listening to a wide range of music and can spend hours in an art gallery I am, frankly, devoid of all drawing/painting ability beyond that developed during primary school and could make similar statements about my musical ability. Likewise, although I love the theatre, I have always had a near-pathological fear of involvement in drama. How surprising it is, then, to find that my passion for science communication/public engagement with science was given a game-changing sideways shove (e.g. here) by involvement with our local Turner Contemporary gallery through the Canterbury Festival of Arts, and I then found myself on stage (here) … life, eh?

For all their positive reinforcement, these events are limited in their scope. Of more impact, I suspect, are the effects of people. Focusing still on the genesis and development of my career, and omitting family and friends by conscious choice, there are a few people who are worthy of mention. I went to a relatively small village primary school, starting at a time when the ‘received wisdom’ was such that all education ought to be left to the teachers: I could just about count to three on arrival and had no reading or writing skills at all! I am thankful for the teachers there, even the two I struggled with, but I couldn’t point to anyone who had an identifiable influence on future academic and intellectual choices. The step to secondary school was a big one, in all sorts of ways, but here I can identify the good and the not-so-good in terms of teacher input. The head teacher, Mr Mortimer, was a liberal (small ‘l’) by inclination and sought to provide an environment in which we were always challenged and always respected; I retain the fondest of memories of him. It is testament to the school that I specialised in the mathematical sciences only when forced to at the point of selecting which four Advanced Level subjects to study in my final two years. Both of my ‘A’-level Physics teachers came to the fore at that stage, for very different reasons. When I confided to one of them that I was considering the study of physics at university, he flatly dismissed my ambition with the statement that I might offer merely “good second class material”. I lived under the curse of that label for many years before finally being released from it; teachers beware: words have power, you should know that better than most. Peter Fayers was altogether different: as a newly qualified teacher with a good physics degree he taught half the course – and did so with a level of energy and of imagination that matched his intellectual ability. His was the confidence and inspiration I needed. Evidence of his care for those of us fortunate to have him as a teacher back then arrived by e-mail almost 30 years later: he had tracked me down to my University department in order to ask me to return to the school and give a talk to a new generation of ‘A’-level students. His note included the question “are you still using black ink?”. I found this astonishing: my minor rebellion against the school’s norm of blue ink should have been noticed and remembered, and then recalled after all those years. (The answer is “yes” by the way.) I returned to give talks many times after that first kind invitation – even after Peter’s retirement – and most recently to help with a ‘Chaos Theory workshop’ earlier this year (derived from this).
Part of the school ’photo, taken in 1971 as I was about to leave; it was easy to spot Mr Mortimer and Peter Fayers, both of whom I have picked out using their initials, but I found my younger self (at the back) only by spotting some of my friends of the time!

Curtains! Lights up! Ah, the interlude … Despite the poorly chosen comments of the teacher alluded to earlier, I was ‘supposed’ to go to Cambridge, or was it Oxford? In fact, the Head had even informed me of which college I was to apply for (his old one, naturally); I scuppered his plans by doing less well than anticipated at Applied Maths. There was a nuisance value associated with this apparent failure of course, as well as a bit of wounded pride, but it was a relief if I’m honest as I doubt I’d have fitted in terribly well as things stood in the early ’70s. However, because of the way the applications process had been set up to cater for the entrance exams and so on, I hadn’t completed the normal university application forms in time and so an entirely ‘vacant’ year beckoned. The term ‘Gap Year’ wasn’t in use back then, and given that I was to become one of the first (the first?) from my post-war local-authority housing estate to go to university, and certainly the first in my extended family, these niceties were more than a little novel. Apart from registering to re-sit the less-good A-level, which was more of a matter of pride than necessity, I therefore set about finding a job. My dad found me some temporary sub-contracting work on a building site, which was back-breaking – I mixed concrete for weeks for a team laying curb stones around a new development – but paid well, and in cash; I had no fingerprints for a while thereafter: all worn away. But, by happy chance, my local agricultural college (sadly now closed) advertised for a junior laboratory technician; four A-levels rendered me over-qualified, and I was quite open with them about only staying until I got a university place somewhere, but the Head of Department, Prof. Selman, offered me the job anyway. The work was tedious – lots of washing up and similar – but that was OK as the people were fun, and I later put myself in for A-level Logic in order to have an intellectual challenge on the side-lines. Of more impact in the longer-term was finding that I was trusted more and more by some of the academics to work well beyond the confines of my job description. Thus, I learnt how to estimate aphid populations on hop leaves using a logarithmic scale, to breed fruit flies in order to harvest the salivary glands of the maggot phase (- get it just right and it’s possible to watch cell division in action: at which stage I had to mount suitably stained samples on slides for student work), to find and collect specific hedgerow and downland plants, to take and develop photographs using IR-sensitive film, … This ‘failure’ actually turned into the most positive of experiences: a valuable life-lesson.
Although it was closed several years ago, Wye Agricultural College was, at the time, a constituent college of the University of London. I was the junior of three technicians who had some space in the low-rise section shown here as it now is; to the left are teaching labs. and, upstairs, research labs and offices – all of which became the core of ‘my patch’ for the duration.

On to the University of Leicester, where I lose count of the people I met who had an influence on future career directions. None of the lecturers in what was then the relatively small Physics Department – 22 of us graduated in 1975 as I recall – failed to have an impact, which was predominantly positive, although sometimes quirky. In passing, even the people I’ve come across who are never likely to make it to my list of favourites – far from it in some cases – have been able at least to induce a positive contribution: sometimes, learning what not to do is as important as the converse. I’ll choose not to dwell too much on my undergraduate period in this post since I’ll be alluding to it again in the series. I must however record a few people of note. John Beeby was an amazing teacher, and held a place of honour in my affections for being one of the first ‘big cheeses’ to invite me, along with some of my contemporaries, to his home and treat us as colleagues – albeit a long way back along the career road; Peter Maguire, a geologist, taught an optional course in geophysics and nearly – very nearly, despite the requirement to camp on the slopes of volcanoes for weeks on end – persuaded me to undertake a PhD in the area with him. Of more long-term impact were those with whom I developed a relationship that went beyond my student days. Colin Norris, for example, who unwittingly brought about my first bit of student ‘unpleasantness’ – he forgot to turn up to a lecture and I drew the ‘short straw’ and was sent to fetch him – grew enormously in my scientific landscape whilst I was doing a PhD; he went on to do a great job as physical sciences director at the Diamond Light Source during a period when I was using it as a visiting researcher. Then we come to John Enderby, under who’s supervision I did my final year research project and with whom I ‘signed up’ to do a PhD thereafter. The PhD began in the September following my graduation; unfortunately, John was away until the following January (- this was before e-mail or fax remember, and even long-distance ’phone calls were an expensive rarity) and no-one in the research group was completely clear about was I was supposed to be doing. Something of a baptism through fire one might say, but ‘what doesn’t kill you will make you stronger’ … or so the saying goes. The ‘hero’ of the moment was Alan Howe, who guided me through those first few months when, in common with many PhD students, ‘throwing in the towel’ seemed like the obvious thing to do on many occasions. John remained an important figure in my career for a long time thereafter, and I am grateful to have been able to work with him, but it is to Alan I owe the bigger debt in terms of helping me to shape my research ethic: his legacy lives on. Although now reduced to the exchange of Christmas letters, Alan is nevertheless the one ex-Leicester person with whom I remain in contact. There is a long list of people associated with what became a decade at the University of Leicester that I could, and perhaps should mention – but we’d be here for ages and so I shall stop at this point …
A farewell gift from my fellow early-career colleagues at Leicester by way of a tongue-in-cheek recognition of my attempts to improve our lot: “To Bob, To enable you to continue stirring”. They evidently couldn’t find a suitable wooden spoon, so this had to suffice; it did the job well enough.

After Leicester came the spallation neutron source, later named ISIS, at the Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, RAL. I was privileged to work here during the final few years of construction of this major international research facility. The longer-term benefit to my career of this intensive experience is inestimable, and the camaraderie associated with bringing such a major machine to its successful first operations in December 1984 is something I’ll never forget. Countless people helped to shape my professional world-view during my time at the RAL but I’ll mention only two here: Spencer Howells and Alan Leadbetter. I remain grateful to Spencer for his long-standing kindness which began with the loan of his charming cottage when my wife, one year old daughter and I first moved to the RAL. Unbeknownst to me, Alan had been chosen as the science director for the ISIS project just prior to my interview and so sat on the selection panel. We had a discussion about science, as one does, during which I criticised one of his research papers (- it was all very constructive: anger should play no part in scientific challenge, although pride may be wounded for a while). A measure of the person he was is that I was appointed not despite that discussion but, in part, because of it. I developed a huge respect for his leadership, and still regard him as a benchmark inspiration in that regard. We have been in contact many times since those days, during which time he’s had a formative influence on the nature and content of the talks on glass I deliver to non-expert audiences.
By good fortune, Spencer and his family were seconded to the USA and needed house-sitters at a time when we were finding it hard to rent a house near RAL whilst we waited for a buyer for our house in Leicester: we occupied part of this lovely place. (It took almost a year to sell our Leicester house as the Midlands market had 'slumped'; the Thames Valley region, by contrast, was buoyant and as a result we never managed to buy a house during our time in Oxfordshire.)

The next stop was the University of Kent’s Physics Laboratory, which was later merged with Chemistry, under my headship, in order to create the School of Physical Sciences. It is from this base that I retire at the end of September. Once again, it would be all-but impossible to mention everyone who deserves to be. I’ll limit myself to three, and keep even that to a brief statement, since more information will emerge quite naturally in related posts on university life and on the nomadic development of my research activities. John Strange was Head of Department when I arrived and to him I therefore owe, in part, my job; beyond that I learned a huge amount about the ins and outs of running a university department – indeed, much of what was subsequently achieved was of necessity built upon foundations he laid. I was paired with Alan Chadwick, a chemist, from very early on and given the task of running the Chemical Physics BSc course with him. Sadly, this excellent degree programme is now closed down; it was a wonderful synthesis of elements of the Physics and of the Chemistry degree programmes which produced some of the most rounded science graduates I have ever known. Alan re-kindled my nascent interest in chemistry and thereby opened anew the potential for research across the interface between the physical sciences, and beyond, that was to become the keynote of my research career. It was also with Alan that I got back into archaeology in more recent years through a joint contribution to the conservation of Henry VIII’s Mary Rose (here). Ann Edwards is now living in the USA with her family, but in 1986 she was graduating with a BSc in Chemical Physics and then began working with me as my first ever PhD student. It would be hard to encapsulate adequately my gratitude to her for being exactly the right person to take on this novice academic on his first step into the world of university research as a fledgling academic (here, 4th paragraph).
My wife’s line drawing of the Physics Laboratory of the late ’80s, from a viewpoint now build upon, and showing the dome of the original student observatory; this drawing was used on the cover of countless departmental publications in following years. On the right is my very first graduating class of Chemical Physics students (my all-time favourite degree programme) showing not only me but the three people I’ve chosen to highlight: Ann Edwards (front row, left), John Strange (front, 5th from the right) and Alan Chadwick (back row, 3rd from the left; travel left three more places and you’ll reach the younger me).

Again and again I have noted the partial nature of this post: a series of all-too-brief snapshots of some of the events and people to have played a role in shaping the development and evolution of my career. However, it’s already the longest single post I’ve written and I question the wisdom of digging much deeper or going much broader this side of the auto-biography I will probably never write.


Footnotes
* … and to add context to this, one might recall that rationing only finally disappeared when I was two years old; I grew up on one of the many post-war council estates ('social housing') created during the reconstruction phase -which was, no doubt, a good period for my dad: a highly skilled bricklayer). The ‘cold war’ – one manifestation of which was the space race – had already begun when I was born and I retain, for example, vivid memories of the 1962 Cuba Blockade and humanity’s countdown to nuclear war. Later public service leaflets, delivered to every home in the UK, could be seen to be deeply flawed by even the most early-stage scientist.

# … including this synopsis of the official enquiry into President Kennedy’s shocking assassination, which was followed not long afterwards by the equally upsetting murder of Martin Luther-King.

Wednesday, 22 July 2015

The Girt Pike

(Reflections on a life in science:  #1 beginnings and transitions)

“ ‘It’s so beautiful,’ said Mrs Rendall, looking wonderingly at the great olive stripes and the bright speckles on its flank. ‘… I had no idea it was so beautiful! I almost feel sorry.’ ‘I feel sorry, missus,’ said Robert, his voice a little choked …
In his house … there would always be an overexposed photograph on the wall of the self-conscious and proud little fellow trying to hold up a pike that was too long and heavy for him. There would always be a photograph of the catch, laid out on the lawn beside a yardstick.
He was haunted by how beautiful the pike had been when it was freshly out of the water, and how its beauty had already diminished when it had been out for only an hour. He knew instinctively that beauty should last forever, and that this world would never be perfected until beauty was perpetual.”

Louis de Bernières penned these words in his gently evocative book Notwithstanding . He uses the situation of a boy who realises a particular ambition – a goal of mythic proportions within the limited horizons of his world – to probe the tussle between achievement and loss which is so often attendant on major events or transitions in life. All such change is intrinsically irreversible in that we are ourselves changed by it, albeit perhaps in ways that may seem imperceptibly small at the time. This is the story that comes to mind as I begin to write the handful of posts I find queuing up in my head and waiting impatiently to tumble out: reflections on a career in academic science as I approach the transition to retirement. Why write it all down one might ask: well, to paraphrase at least one author it is, I hope, sufficient to say that I write in order to discover what I think …

There is, however, a more easily defined catalyst for beginning to write this now rather than post-retirement. Put simply, a colleague of mine shared with me his nervousness at the likelihood of being asked to make a valedictory speech at whatever retirement ‘do’ my department might organise. Whilst he’s aware of my various contributions since his arrival near the turn of the century, he necessarily has a far sketchier knowledge of what went before and he wondered whether I might not try to fill in the gaps. Why not, given that I was minded to write something anyway irrespective of the obvious potential for self-indulgence and self-congratulation (or, perhaps, self-criticism). In passing, I ought to note that our ‘facilitators’ – oh, how I dislike that term – at a whole-day event, designed to prepare me, my wife and about 20 other souls for this change in our lives, were initially firm in their stated preference for the label “freelance” over “retired”. They went on to use “retired” and its derivatives almost exclusively however, and so shall I …

I have been fortunate in having four decades in research, and many more years as a ‘scientist’ – indeed, from at least the age of nine or ten I think. There’s no need to repeat what I have posted already by way of snapshots from the postgraduate/professional years (e.g. here and here) but it might prove interesting to explore a few of the wider or more generic aspects of this one scientist’s working life over time, even if only by way of sketches made with a broad brush. I am by both choice and inclination something of a nomad: my research activities have changed a lot over the years, albeit within the overall landscape of liquids and amorphous materials (see here and here for a bit more by way of scientific background). For this reason, if for no other, I have never expected to land the ‘girt pike’ in the sense of results that win awards or medals, a situation under-girded by a form of the ‘Imposter Syndrome’ suffered by many, perhaps most, academics. It’s not that the outputs and outcomes of my efforts and those of the evolving team with whom I’ve partnered lack interest, importance, impact or influence; rather, it’s that what has motivated and driven me has instead been the inestimable pleasure of working with talented and creative people to solve the intriguing puzzles of nature. To use my metaphor one last time, this is ‘the girt pike’ for me: being able to work for so long within a professional landscape offering such gems. I recently heard someone speak well on the fact that it’s not what we’ve done that gives us value, but who we are. Such a statement begs some large and philosophical questions of course, which I’ll not even attempt to explore here, but a wander around aspects of my science-filled life might nevertheless prove revealing – to me at least.
A ‘shelfie’: some of the now-dated Ladybird books from my earlier years which still survive in my study today – illustrative of the spread in my primary school reading.
There’s nothing like beginning at the beginning, as Dylan Thomas might say. My first declared primary school enthusiasm was not for science but for history. This transmuted over the years into an abiding interest in archaeology, fueled by the eventual addition of scientific insights and still providing highlights to my working life (here). I had great fun as a teenager spending my weekends as a volunteer for the local archaeological team (here perhaps, although my memory is a bit fuzzy on which body the group was affiliated to). However, even in Year Two at primary school there must have been some embryonic disposition towards the sciences: how else is one to explain the fact that, amongst the less pleasant memories I have of that year (huddling around the cast iron stove that provided our only classroom heating, waiting for the milk to thaw and shrink back into the third-pint bottles, and being forced to sit on my hands when I spoke in order to be ‘cured’ of gesticulating) I still recall having to copy off the board “The Russians have put a satellite into space, aren’t they clever” (here).
Within a few years I was doodling designs for spaceships and ray guns, and reading the comic-strip exploits of ‘Dan Dare: pilot of the future’ in my brother’s Eagle comic. My own regular weekly reading was found in the pages of Look & Learn, which had a distinctly more sober-sided content. (I’d been reading Look & Learn since its very first edition in 1962; sadly, my collection of the first hundred or so was lost in one of my parents’ later house-moves.) It’s perhaps useful to add some context here by noting that we had no TV to divert us until I was nine years old or thereabouts – and even then, given what was on offer and the inevitable headaches gained by staring at the 405-line (‘lo-res’!) monochrome sets of the day, one didn’t watch much; the radio wasn’t much better in terms of catering to younger people. 

During my early and teenage years of secondary school I started taking things apart, developed some naïve skill in mixing chemicals and in crystal-growing using the wonderful chemistry sets then freely available (similar to this) and started to take astronomy a lot more seriously. I even kept the occasional logbook describing all this (see the images below). Evidently, I survived the hazards I entertained, and I’m grateful to my parents for trusting me in this – in fact, they let me have part of the shed so I could ‘experiment’. Using a hacksaw to dissect an acid gel-filled battery was the least of the risks: I recall injecting potassium permanganate and other solutions into potatoes to ‘see what would happen’ (- yes, I’d obtained a syringe from somewhere), setting up a small methylated spirit-powered still to try to produce my own distilled water, using the power supply from my brother’s train set to electroplate stuff … and worse. A few years later, once I’d passed my driving test, I graduated to evening classes in observational astronomy and I could more easily visit the nearest sizeable library. I got the first of two parking tickets – thus far – at one such library visit: an example of the ‘perils’ of losing track of time when beguiled by some shiny new facts.

Even then, science was not my only intellectual love: archaeology was still in the running and I’d discovered a fondness for English Literature – the latter no doubt arising from a childhood spent under the chronic influence of asthma. (Before effective palliative care was available, adrenaline injected slowly into a vein by our local doctor was the norm for a serious attack, followed by a few static days in recovery; reading was one of the only diversions.) The constraints of selecting four ‘A-level’ subjects at 16 forced a choice. I decided to go down the physical sciences pathway and studied Physics, Chemistry, Pure Maths and Applied Maths; other interests remained, but had to take a back seat thereafter. The desire not to specialise remained however. Indeed, working in an agricultural college as a laboratory technician for year before going to university re-opened my eyes to the life sciences, and I even studied in my own time towards ‘A’-level Logic during the year – just for the fun of it. Even though I eventually, and due to a clerical error, undertook a degree in Physics rather than the combined sciences degree I had applied for (see here, fourth paragraph) I have been fortunate to have been able to broaden the scope of my work over the years since then, as noted above.
Logbook (aka a simple ring-bound notebook from the newsagent) entries on early experiments with electroplating and the insides of batteries, together with a couple of surviving ‘tools of the trade’ – a pocket microscope and an astronaut’s pen: necessities in their time.
As I approach retirement from my academic career I am grateful that this can in no way signify retirement from being a scientist, since that’s intrinsic to the person I am. There is undoubtedly a transition into another phase of whatever that term actually means. The themes I am minded to explore within this series of posts might be described as follows: 
  • Inspirational influences and key people: who and what got me into the areas of science I have explored; 
  • developing instrumentation and facilities: starting out before the internet existed, before the electronic calculator even, through to the development and use of large-scale, leading-edge international research facilities;
  • ‘random walks’ in research: life at the interfaces between traditional subjects and the serendipity one finds there; 
  • ‘the day job’: teaching and all that accompanies it, along with the good, the bad and the ugly of committees and of leadership and so on. 
In all of this I have decided to define a reasonably tight focus on my scientific career, although it is surely self-evident that no aspect of one’s life can ever truly be ‘isolated’ from any other. Thus, in that sense, the posts will be somewhat ‘artificial’ since important influences arising from relationships, health, politics and so on will not be explored other than to provide a bit of context here and there. Time will tell what actually emerges, but this is emphatically not conceived as an autobiography. The other themed posts will emerge as and when I get the time to write them, but hopefully within the next couple of months.

____________________________________________________________________
Postscript (3/9/16): this is the actual series of posts in which I reflect on a few themes associated with my life and career as a research scientist and university academic:
1) The Girt Pike – beginnings and transitions; i.e. the above.
2) Do Labels Last a Lifetime? – people and other influences.
3) Nomadic Research: random walk or purposeful journey? – a timeline in research.
4) Tools of the Trade – instruments and gadgets.
5) Suitcase Science: travelling in hope – tales from a travelling scientist.
6) Why so many? – gender balance in the research team
7) Committees: the Good, the Bad and the Ugly – making things work: discussion, consensus and decision?
8) Large-scale Facilities for Small-scale Science – the big ‘toys’ I’ve helped to build and to nurture
9a) Experiments in Teaching and Learning – teaching at a university (part 1)
9b) Flipping Lectures – teaching at a university (part 2)

Sunday, 21 June 2015

Chaos and Regency Style

The week leading up to 7th June had evidently set the elegant Regency heart of Cheltenham throbbing with the annual Science Festival. I had never been before, which is hardly surprising as it falls in term-time and the timing coincides almost precisely with exam-marking deadlines. This year was different however: not only had my partial retirement freed up a couple of days in the week but I was a part of the team* presenting a modified version of the Chaos Cabaret I wrote about here. Even so, I could only be there for the day of the rehearsals and performance.
Source: http://www.cheltenhamfestivals.com/science/whats-on/2015/the-chaos-cabaret/
Rather than being a full-on and sober-minded science education event per se, Chaos Cabaret majors on fun and then injects some science along the way, which in no way signifies any sense of laissez-faire within the team – far from it. With the performance scheduled from 5:30, almost every minute from our midday access to the rehearsal venue had to be used to the full. Between the first performance at the 2014 Canterbury Festival (which I reflected on in the latter half of an earlier post, here) and this major showing at Cheltenham, Frank had modified and extended the script, two of our three musicians and two of the four actors had changed, and of course the ‘feel’ of the venue was completely different. On this occasion I had the privilege of sitting in on the entire process rather than only the dress rehearsal. It was fascinating to watch their creativity as script was melded with physical action and the whole was wrapped into a framework of music. The teamwork was inspiring. Having said that, the pace was such that there was almost necessarily a tension between the actors’ need for an element of spontaneity – which also helped them get through the all-too-brief time they’d had to master the new script – with the musicians’ understandable need for clear prompts. Apart from a couple of minor observations on the scientific accuracy of phrases in the script, my contributions comprised the folding of a couple of paper airplanes (at which I excel by the way) and being an obstacle. The latter required only that I sat on a chair in the middle of the rehearsal space to simulate the need for the actors to dive in and out of the audience during the performance; this was a role I considered myself born to.
Rehearsals: Frank (foreground) watching Tamsin (right, in the raincoat)
and crew working out their movements for one of the final scenes.
Lack of time or not, everyone needs to eat. Not only did this give me my first real look at all the events underway in the umpteen venues en route, but once I’d registered – as a ‘performer’ I might add – I became the proud owner of my very first Green Room pass in the form of a wrist band. This gave me a chance to stare at the stars of course, and in this context that included a couple of people one might see on TV like Jim Al-Khalili and Mark Miodownik: ‘heroes’ of science communication. The key thing, apart from eating, was to get a peek at the performance venue – the Pillar Room in the Town Hall, which was as grand as it sounds – and to chat to the lovely volunteers/helpers who’d be arranging the seating, operating the lighting and so on. Having said that, I was also keen to see what else was going on: the event is huge, and I’m now very keen to use the flexibility of my retired, or should that be ‘freelance’ status next year to pay a more extended visit. In passing, I’ll share with you the sound engineer’s excellent idea for producing something akin to the noise of a tornado: hold a microphone in front of the air conditioner’s fan and turn the amplifier up to 11.

We had almost an hour for a dress rehearsal before the performance itself. Apart from setting up a webcam on a tripod so I could attempt to record the performance on my laptop (which failed miserably I’m sorry to say as the sound quality was dreadful) I was given the role of resident artist. For anyone who knows just how poor my drawing skills are this statement ought to cause serious amusement. Thankfully, the need didn’t extend beyond drawing a few matchstick people on the sheets of a flipchart: even so, they were grotesque. I really ought to have photographed one of them properly, but there is a ghost of an image in the background of the picture below; unfortunately, this is the cartoon of someone who was quite evidently unsuccessfully ‘beamed’ through a Star Trek style transporter …

It was most gratifying, and somewhat scary, to learn from a volunteer steward that tickets had been sold to all the seats in the room. Thankfully, the performance itself seemed, to me, to go reasonably well; later feedback was positive – phew! This was an opinion not shared by everyone, sadly: one individual left after less than five minutes, telling me as he did so that he found the performance to be devoid of science. However, I discovered afterwards from my wife, who was sat next to him, that he’d been disappointed by an earlier performance as well – and in that case the speaker was one of the ‘greats’ and a truly accomplished communicator; I guess there’s no pleasing some people. As with the version we premiered at the Canterbury Festival in 2014, the performance ended with about 15 minutes of Q&A fielded by me. It was an interesting session, notably because several of the questions were not about Chaos Theory at all (such as the one on ‘Intelligent Design’ and another on parallel universes). However, the really nice thing was the fact that questions came from a wide range of people: the young and the not-so-young, people who knew a little about science and those who were there to learn, and men and women in roughly equal number.

The Q&A session; an example of the flipchart artwork sits in the background.
I’ve no idea where this will go now. Frank has been chatting to a very well-known animations studio about extending the schools work we’ve started and perhaps developing an online version of the whole thing, and he’s already busy putting together funding bids. It’s clear to me that there is a potential demand to take this concept into schools; it’s easy to see how one might use ‘Chaos Theory Workshops’ to get science and arts students working together to generate their own Chaos Cabarets. If this can be accomplished it would tick a lot of boxes as far as I am concerned. Time will tell, as is always the case.

*  Frank Burnet conceived the idea, with project manager Emma Weitkamp, and wrote the script; Joanna Ive wrote the highly innovative score; our lead musician, accomplished as an improviser, was Sam Bailey; the lead actor was the hugely impressive Tamsin Fessey of The Angel Exit theatre company and she had with her a talented trio of colleagues (Simon Carroll-Jones, Jennifer Jackson and Tim Bell).

Tuesday, 2 June 2015

Finding the Needle

This is an edited version of a guest post in the August 2014 edition of Laboratory News magazine within their "Celebrating Great British Science" series; I nominated the work of John Enderby and Peter Egelstaff in the 1960s in the use of isotope substitution as a great British scientific breakthrough. I have included this version merely for completeness and ease of access - the original may currently be viewed here. 

The phrase ‘looking for a needle in a haystack’ was born as an idiom for the supremely difficult task of sifting out the kernel of an answer from the vastness or complexity of the particular situation in question.  Neutron diffraction with isotope substitution, NDIS, is one of the methods developed in the physical sciences to tackle just such a situation.  This is a sketch of its story, and of its origins in the work of two remarkable scientists almost five decades ago.

In case you missed it, 2013 saw the centenary of x-ray diffraction (e.g. see here) and a celebration of the work of the Nobel prize-winning Braggs; in 2020 we’ll reach the analogous landmark for Chadwick’s discovery of the neutron (here) – worthy of its own article. The early decades of the twentieth century were heady times for the physical sciences.  Whilst the exploitation of x-rays for research happened relatively swiftly after their discovery by Röntgen in 1895, and demonstrations of the analogous potential for neutrons appeared as early as 1936 (Rep. Prog. Phys. 16, 1, 1953), it wasn’t until the mid-1940s that the first diffraction experiments using genuinely practicable beam intensities were conducted by Clifford Shull and Ernest Wollan.  There is a reason for this.  X-ray beams could be produced in abundance and the x-ray interacts strongly with matter whereas, by contrast, neutron beams are necessarily of much lower flux and interact only weakly with the nuclei of atoms.  (To discover more about the neutron sources currently supported by and for the UK scientific community, take a look at the respective websites for the ISIS Neutron and Muon Source and the Institut Laue-Langevin.)  However, the neutron has attributes – including its weakly interacting nature – which make it a wonderful probe of liquids and solids, and once this had been established there was, and continues to be, a strong desire to use neutron beams to the full.  Because the neutron has no charge, its primary interaction is not with the electron cloud surrounding an atom (as it would be with the x-ray) but with the central nucleus; the very weakness of this interaction makes a fully quantitative analysis of the resultant data far more tractable, even if the sample is held within a relatively massive containment vessel.  Moreover, the neutron has mass and this means one can not only use its wave-like properties for diffraction experiments on the positions of atoms, but it becomes possible to probe the dynamics of a material’s atoms as well – as first demonstrated in the 1950s by Betram Brockhouse.  Crucially for this story, there is more: because neutrons scatter from the nuclei of atoms within a material, the nature of that event is affected by the particular isotopes present.  Thus, whilst x-rays are sensitive only to the elements present, neutrons are also sensitive to the admixture of isotopes associated with those elements … suffice it to say that neutrons are marvellous.
A (rather poor) image taken from a special edition of the London Illustrated News marking the 25th anniversary of the reign of George V: these two pages celebrate the scientific advances made in these years, and the images around the article include some 'big' names in the formative stages of modern science.
Returning now to the problem at hand, we need to consider the ‘haystack’.  In the May 2014 edition of Laboratory News, and then in this series of blog posts, I wrote a short piece about disordered materials: obtaining information on the positions of atoms within the regular array that is a crystal is one thing – take away that sample-wide order and one faces a more challenging problem altogether.  Given a liquid or an amorphous solid (e.g. a glass), neither of which possess order to the arrangement of their atoms beyond that driven by short-range chemical/electrostatic forces (i.e. over a distance corresponding to only a few atomic diameters), how does one extract quantitative information about the distribution of atoms of one element with respect to the other elements present?  We may illustrate the complexity of this question by considering a ‘simple’ amorphous material containing only two elements: A and B.  For a full understanding of the atomic-scale structure of the material one needs to know the distribution of A atoms around Bs (and equivalently, Bs around As), A atoms around other As, and Bs around other Bs.  Thus, from one diffraction experiment yielding a single ‘combined’ data set – the structure factor –  we must attempt to extract three distinct distributions, the partial structure factors: this is, self-evidently, not possible.  The complexity of the puzzle increases rapidly if we add more elements; in general, there are ½N(N+1) partial structure factors for a sample comprising N elements.  Tissue-regenerative/anti-bacterial bioactive glasses studied by my own team in recent years, for instance, include materials containing up to six elements: there would in this case be 21 distinct partial structure factors contributing to the single experimentally determined curve.  Add to this the fact that the scientifically key partial structure factor may be associated with an element present at low concentration and/or which scatters neutrons only weakly, and therefore making a relatively weak contribution, and the problem truly begins to warrant the idiom ‘looking for a needle in a haystack’. 

At this point our two scientific ‘heroes’, Peter Egelstaff and John Enderby (later Prof. Sir John Enderby FRS in recognition of his contribution) enter the fray.  In a paper published in July 1966 in Philosophical Magazine (Phil. Mag. 14, 961, 1966), with research team member D.M. North, they successfully demonstrated an elegant method by which one might overcome these limitations in the right circumstances.  The key step was to make use of the isotope-dependency of neutron scattering.  If we return for a moment to our A+B sample, imagine that element A has a stable isotope, let’s designate it A*, which scatters neutrons with a different ‘strength’ to the naturally occurring mixture of isotopes that make up A.  Imagine now two samples, identical in all respects save for the fact that in one of them the natural A is replaced with isotope A*; x-ray diffraction data gathered from these two samples would be indistinguishable from one another.  If, however, we conduct separate neutron diffraction experiments on them we’d obtain a total structure factor for A+B and another for A*+B, each of these totals will of course be the combination of three distinct partial structure factors: AB, AA and BB in the one case, and A*B, A*A* and BB in the other.  Subtracting one data set from the other means that we have immediately removed the BB partial term since it is common to both – leaving only those partial structure factors related to element A.  If we take this further by adding a third sample, and corresponding diffraction results, in which the mix of stable isotopes varies again (e.g. a mix of A with A*, or perhaps using a stable isotope of element B) then we’ll have another data set to add to our armoury.  At this point, by analogy with the basic methods for solving simultaneous equations in mathematics, all three of our partial structure factors may be derived: we had three ‘variables’ (A around B, A around A, and B around B) and now we have the necessary three ‘equations’. 

It is not always necessary to be able to derive every single distinct partial structure factor of course; sometimes all that is needed is to narrow the field a little.  Take for instance some of my own team’s work on bioactive glasses.  A ‘simple’ silicate glass containing some calcium and hydrogen will, if the composition is right, dissolve in body fluid (e.g. blood plasma) and supply a chemical signal to the body which promotes the formation of the mineral component of bone: these materials can provide a scaffold for bone regeneration.  Central to the understanding of how this material works is gaining an understanding of why it is that Ca leaves the glass at the rate it does.  In other words, we need to know where the Ca sits in relation to its surrounding atoms: we need the partial structure factors associated with Ca.  Now, given the presence of four elements (Si, Ca, O, H) a single neutron diffraction experiment yields a structure factor comprising 10 partial components; calcium’s contribution to this is effectively hidden within the total.  Thankfully, nature has provided us with a suitable stable isotope of calcium, Ca-44, which enables precisely the sort of experiment outlined above.  The majority silica component to our diffraction data could be subtracted out, along with the OH terms, leaving only the partial structure factors associated with calcium’s environment, as shown below.  Of the six oxygen atoms surrounding the average Ca atom, only two of them tie the Ca into the silicate glass network by forming bridges to Si – the others bridge only to H or are non-bridging.  The mystery of calcium dissolution is thereby solved (J. Mater. Chem. 15, 2369, 2005). 
Isotope-enriched sample data is on the left, the difference between the two is shown on the right, from which our conclusions were ultimately drawn.
This is but one example of the continuing beauty and the strength represented by John Enderby and Peter Egelstaff’s breakthrough; here is a method by which, metaphorically speaking, the ‘hay’ may be removed in order to see the ‘needle’.  From their first experiments in the 1960s, through the development of high flux neutron sources of the 1970s, and on to the remarkably powerful and diverse facilities UK scientists have access to today, their ground-breaking work continues to enable exciting new science.  Indeed, earlier this year the Royal Society elected another talented expert in the use of isotopic substitution to their pantheon of Fellows: Alan Soper.  Although the use of hugely important complementary probes such as solid state NMR and x-ray absorption spectroscopy have emerged in the intervening years, together with computer modelling, NDIS remains a powerful technique in the worldwide study of materials, and there is little sign yet of any decline to its scientific impact.

I am indebted to colleagues Alan Soper and Robert McGreevy at the ISIS Neutron and Muon Source for their helpful advice and input.

Biographical footnote:  I have been publishing research in the field of liquids and amorphous materials for more than three decades - the link to my ORCID account, in which all this work is listed, is accessible via the QR code shown on the right of this post.  A pertinent snippet is that my final year undergraduate project at the University of Leicester was supervised by John Enderby, who later recruited me as a PhD student; we share authorship of four journal papers.  Perhaps surprisingly, given the nature of the above post, it was only afterwards, as a postdoctoral researcher with R. Alan Howe, that the use of neutrons – including the use of NDIS – and later x-rays, emerged as a career theme.


Saturday, 23 May 2015

Cool Week: alchemy to roller-coasting via a film script and some chaos

Some weeks are special, in a good way; this week* has been a classic of its kind: an excellent illustration of where ‘Public Engagement’ can lead if one is pre-disposed and disciplined enough to say “yes” by default. I spent Monday afternoon in a primary school with two Year Five classes and by Wednesday morning I was discussing potential project ideas with someone from the re-opening Dreamland amusement park in Margate. Into this pot went an extended skype interview on some recent secondary school workshops, agreeing to deliver a series of U3A talks and checking the science content of two scripts – one for a stage performance, the other for a film. Much of this is outside of my ‘day job’ of course, but that simply underlines the benefits of being able to work part-time.

When I’m asked what sort of public engagement/science communications I get involved with I usually kick off with statements implying a pre-disposition to working with adult lay audiences (e.g. in this guest post, and here), but the truth is that I still love spending time in schools as well. On the whole, this tends mostly to be in the context of Year 12/13 groups – but there are exceptions (e.g. here). Monday’s outing to a local primary school (here) was the second time I’d been in a room with Year Five pupils (so, about 10 years old). However, the first event was relatively ‘safe’ in the sense that I was a mystery reader – I simply read from a book I’d found which wove science into an age-appropriate story (see here, final paragraph) – whereas I was on this occasion much more accessible to the class: distinctly unsafe! My brief was to play the role of an alchemist and to engage with the five groups in each of two classes as they undertook a series of experiments. The back-story had been well-defined by the two excellent class teachers, Miss Brisley and Miss Holbrough: I was to be introduced enigmatically as The Alchemist; apparently I lived at a place called Dragon Vine Towers on Alchemy Island, and although I already had an apprentice I was on the look-out for more. I’d travelled to the school through a portal – de rigueur these days I suspect. The potential for disaster was present from the first moment I stepped into the room in that the pupils were given a few minutes to ask me about my work (as an alchemist that is: tricky in itself given my professional pedigree). Although I had mastered the basics of the back-story, I soon discovered that they’d prepared wall displays showing ‘maps’ of my island home and had explored this ‘territory’ in all sorts of contexts. I had not prepared myself for the persistent, no-limits probing of 10-year olds: lesson number one …

“Where’s your portal?”   
“I don’t like to frighten people so I only switch it on in quiet places … the remote control is in my rucksack … No, you can’t see it, it’s top secret … no, sadly I’m not allowed to let you try it.”
“Why does your white coat say University of Kent?”   
“I called in there on my way and borrowed it.”
“Aren’t you Mr Newport’s dad?”   
“Who’s he?”
“What do you really do?”   and on and on.
This is the set of investigative tasks – experiments – the Year Five pupils were undertaking.

The experiments got started, with small groups of pupils moving in a carefully orchestrated way between the set-piece investigations which had been replicated in their two classrooms. I just enjoyed myself, kneeling at all the tables in turn and chatting with them about what they were doing, what they had observed, what it might mean and why it was important to write it all down. It also gave me the most wonderful opportunity to try to answer their many and varied questions – not least of which were the variations on the theme of how gold is really made (no, it’s not quite like Minecraft … thank goodness my grandsons have inducted me into the basics). I have no idea what short- or longer-term impact I will have had on these Year Five pupils; I can but hope there’ll be some positive legacy from the event. What I am sure of is their impact on me: a couple of hours of sheer fun engaging with these aspiring young people, and without the need to cope with the ongoing extra-lesson pressures piled onto their teachers, almost necessarily leaves one in a better place I think. I can however share with you the tweeted feedback from one of the talented teachers involved ascribing to me an attribute with which I’d not previously been associated:





Dreamland (here) had its heyday in the two decades after WW2, when pre-package holiday crowds filled the lovely sandy beach at Margate and spilled over the road into amusement arcades and food outlets, and into this theme park which boasted a Grade II listed wooden scenic railway roller coaster. I have vague and disjointed memories of being in the throng a few times as a young boy – although never on the roller coaster, not then, not since. Never. Some months ago, the ever-talented head of the Learning team at Turner Contemporary (Karen Eslea) suggested that I contact her homologue at Dreamland once the restoration programme was underway; she wondered whether they might also find a use for a ‘tame scientist’. The catalyst for following up on this advice came in the form of our on-going search for suitable external partners to work alongside final year BSc student projects – hopefully to mutual benefit. On Wednesday I had the pleasure of meeting Donna Watford and of introducing her to my Physics Group Projects colleagues (Vicky Mason and George Dobre). The meeting was a great success and I have high hopes of getting one or two groups of physics students learning from and investing into the Dreamland outreach efforts next academic year. However, given my retirement at the end of September, I’ll not be involved with this myself – my ‘teaching’ is likely to reside within the University of the 3rd Age (here) from then on, and I’m rather looking forward to the change of audience. Who knows, maybe the ‘tame scientist’ idea might yet come to something – in Dreamland.
Source: http://www.dreamland.co.uk/rides-and-attractions/map

I’ve written about my involvement with Chaos Cabaret before (here). Since then I’ve been helping its originator, Frank Burnet (here), to take the concept into secondary schools in the form of workshops wherein the students work on their own journeys from a butterfly flapping its wings to a tornado (- a route postulated by one of the key people in the development of Chaos Theory, see here for example). The workshop idea has been trialled in two schools thus far. We’ve learnt a lot from these trials and there are some exciting possibilities emerging (hopefully, more news to come later). At one of the workshops we had an observer, Charlotte Thorley of the Public Engagement team at Queen Mary College, University of London (here); she is , it seems, undertaking research into science communications – hence the request for an extended Skype interview. It’s all go … . However, to get back to my present focus, the more immediate challenge is a performance of Chaos Cabaret at the Cheltenham Science Festival (here) – including the operatives of the Ministry of Chaos, naturally. The original script needed a revision; given my primary role in the team as their tame physicist (yes, there’s the concept again) I had the pleasure of checking it through for obvious/serious scientific errors. Frank is very good at this: I had rather little to say. Let’s hope the performance runs as smoothly. Apparently, as a ‘performer’, I get access to the Green Room at the Festival; this will be a first for me.

This isn’t the only script I’ve been sent for review this week. The other is for a proposed film to be ready for the 400th anniversary of Shakespeare’s birth in 2016. It’s loosely based on the plot of his ‘Merry Wives of Windsor’, but set in India and with a strong thread of science and engineering woven through it. The writer is a freelance journalist and author, Carole Jahme, with whom I’ve worked before (- on a project for pop-up street theatre during the Cultural Olympiad). Although it took longer than looking through revisions to something I already knew fairly well (Chaos Cabaret), I have to say that I found reading and commenting on this all-new script a lot of fun. I hope it gets funding: I’d like to see the final product.

All-in-all, it’s been a more than averagely busy and varied few days in terms of Public Engagement; definitely a cool week.


* In truth, this isn’t quite as timely as it seems: although I drafted much of this at the time, it’s taken me another week in order to pull it all together into its present form. In passing, I ought also to note that the school staff underwent ‘trial by Ofsted' a week after my visit: if there’s any justice it’ll work out well for them. I’ll edit additional images into the post when they arrive, after being checked against the parental consent/permissions information held by the school – naturally.


Thursday, 26 March 2015

Ma’am, as in Jam: a Grand Day Out

A friend of ours, Fiona Keyte, recently went to Buckingham Palace to collect her richly-deserved MBE: she’s worked tirelessly within a small charity called Time Out which was set up to enable and support the work she and her small army of volunteers does within parts of the local community.  Fiona has now got closer to a member of the Royal family – the Queen no less – than I ever have, or probably ever will.  However, earlier this month I did have a ‘near miss’ …

I’ve written before (e.g. here) about the small projects I have had the privilege of undertaking with some hugely talented people at the Turner Contemporary gallery and ought one day to pull my reflections on these experiences together into a more coherent post.  There is plenty of scope for such an exercise: dropping a scientist into the work of an art gallery is almost bound to generate ‘sparks’, and I have certainly learnt a lot – and perhaps I have changed a little in the process.  In the meantime I thought I might describe my own grand day out at a reception at the gallery in honour of a visit by the Duchess of Cambridge – well, it was only a morning actually and for the most part not very grand, but it was interesting.  Presumably on the basis of my modest input to the work of the Learning Team at the gallery, I received an invitation to the reception and was sufficiently flattered and intrigued to accept.  Having never been invited to anything quite like this before it was all novel to me.  In all honestly this is probably as close to the reason for this brief post as I’ll be able to express: as a scientist and an academic – and presumably it’s the same for most of us – one doesn’t get the opportunity to be a part of this sort of event very often.  Indeed, this was a first for me and I’ve been doing the job for four decades in one place or another.  (It’s not the first time I have posted something along the lines of ‘a day in the life’: see here for an earlier example.  I’ll not write too many, I hope.)

The scene outside Turner Contemporary as I arrived: a flag-seller,
the press and others beginning to stake their respective claims to a spot.

Out of curiosity and an innate need to ‘be prepared’ I turned to Debrett’s, where else, to learn more of the etiquette.  Evidently there are orders of Dukes and Duchesses: only four carry the epithet ‘Royal’ according to Debrett’s (Cambridge, York, Gloucester and Kent – although one might imagine Edinburgh ought to be in there somewhere …) and in conversation one ought to open with “Your Royal Highness” and continue with “Ma’am” – correctly pronounced, naturally.  As it turned out my research was not necessary, although it did inspire my title for this post.  One had to arrive early, and most people got there at least an hour before the royal party were due to arrive, replete with two forms of photo-ID.  Everyone was directed to a large open room in which a handful of chairs and some tea/coffee/water were provided.  It’s good that this particular room has a wonderful view of the sea.  It was also good to be able to catch up with folk I’d not seen for a while and to meet some new people.  But mostly it was standing and waiting whilst, out of our sight, the visitors arrived and were greeted and shown around the current exhibition.  Once the more private events had concluded we were directed into the main foyer – beautifully filled with the sound of a youth orchestra – in order to await the return of the visitors from their viewing.  Those pre-chosen for ‘the line-up’ stood separately from the bulk of us, and in turn in their three small clusters, were introduced to the Duchess; after this there was a speech of welcome before the Duchess went into the room we’d just vacated in order to have some lunch.  With the reception now over, we who had provided the reasonably well-behaved and moderately well-dressed backdrop began to leave. 

In all honesty, I’d think twice before committing more than half a working day for this sort of engagement a second time.  Having said that, I was happy to be able to support the gallery’s work in this small way, glad to have had the chance to chat to people I don’t see often, and pleased to have had a harmless novel experience.  Photography was banned for those of us inside, but there are some images here if you’re interested.

Next stop, if I write according to my current loosely-framed plan, are a few thoughts on some of the committees I've known: the good, the bad and the ugly?